Can Blacktower Spain fare any better than other companies we have looked into? How many of their advisers will come out qualified and registered?
If you have been following Pension Life´s blogs you will know that we have been conducting a series of investigations into qualified and registered financial advisers in various firms. Today is Blacktower Spain – qualified and registered?
IFAs and their clients are invited to add to it, correct it, improve it. Here’s a link to the two registers if you want to double check:
http://www.cii.co.uk/web/app/membersearch/MemberSearch.aspx
https://www.cisi.org/cisiweb2/cisi-website/join-us/cisi-member-directory
Please note that this data is correct as of 9am 25/06/2018
edit: we have been informed that there is a third website we can check for qualifications, so this page is in the process of editing whilst we see if any names appear on the libf members website. 02/07/2018
https://www.libf.ac.uk/members-and-alumni/sps-and-cpd-register
Blacktower has several offices in Spain – so let’s see which one is the best.
Blacktower Spain – Barcelona
Andy Clelland – International Financial Adviser – not on either CII OR CISI register despite a long list of qualifications – not on libf.ac.uk
Francisco Mahfuz – Regional Manager Barcelona – Claims CII and CISI but does NOT appear on either register – not on libf.ac.uk
David Marks – International Financial Adviser – Claims CII – a Mr David Alan Marks DipPFS appears on the CII register. Also Claims CISI but not on the register – not on libf.ac.uk
Bernhard Rufli – International Financial Adviser – again a long list of qualifications claimed but alas NOT ON EITHER CII OR CISI REGISTER!– not on libf.ac.uk
Glenn Stroud – International Financial Adviser – CII registered – not on libf.ac.uk
Barcelona 1 out of 5!
No extra points using the libf register
*************************************
Black Tower Spain – Costa Calida
Keith Littlewood – Regional Manager – Claims a good list of qualifications – does not appear on either register – not on libf.ac.uk
Paul Price – International Financial Adviser – A Paul Anthony Price DipPFS does appear on the CII register – but it says he is based in Chelmsford – not on libf.ac.uk
A possible 1 out of 2 – but only possibly!
No extra points using the libf register
************************************
Blacktower Spain Costa Del Sol
Kenneth Baek – International Financial Adviser – Not on either register – not on libf.ac.uk
Richard Black – International Financial Adviser – claims the title FPC – but does not appear on any register – not on libf.ac.uk
Tim Govaerts – Associate Director – States he IS a CII member but he ISN´T registered
Patrick Macdonald – International Financial Adviser – claims to be a member of both – DOES NOT appear on either register – not on libf.ac.uk EDIT: Patrick Macdonald is now listed on the CISI membership website.
Richard Mills – International Financial Adviser – claims qualifications in CII and CISI – but does not appear on either register – not on libf.ac.uk
Jose Olabarrieta – International Financial Adviser – Not on either register – not on libf.ac.uk
Chris Pickering – International Financial Adviser – He states he is CISI qualified but he IS NOT on the register – not on libf.ac.uk
Craig Webb – International Financial Adviser – No claim to qualifications and not on either register – not on libf.ac.uk
Ian Scholes – International Financial Adviser – Lists that he is CII and he IS CII registered – not on libf.ac.uk
Quentin Sellar – International Financial Adviser – Boast a whole host of qualifications and he IS on the CII register – not on libf.ac.uk
Well done Sellar and Scholes
2 out of 10 for the Costa Del Sol!
No extra points using the libf register
************************************
Blacktower Spain Costa Blanca
Christina Brady – Associate Director – Claims two qualifications in CISI but does not appear on the register – not on libf.ac.uk
Wayne Martin – International Financial Adviser – Claims to be a member of both CII and CISI but only appears on the CII register – not on libf.ac.uk
Dave Diggle – International Financial Adviser – states his expertise is QROPS but he doesn´t appear on either register – not on libf.ac.uk
Richard Samuels – International Financial Adviser – his areas of expertise are Pension Planning/Transfers but he IS NOT on either register – not on libf.ac.uk
Graham Dixon – International Financial Adviser – IS CII registered! – not on libf.ac.uk
Andrew Gibson DipIP – International Financial Adviser – IS CII registered! – not on libf.ac.uk
2 out of 6 for the Costa Blanca team!
No extra points using the libf register
************************************
Gibraltar Head office
John Westwood – Group Managing Director – IS CII registered
Robert Mancera – Director and General Manager – IS CII registered
Ally Kerr – Group Director – Claims CII but DOES NOT appear on the register
Patricia Risso – Non-Executive Director – No claims and not listed on either register
Paul Rhodes – Associate Director – a Mr Paul John Rhodes Lakin ACII is listed on the CII register – could this be him?
Paul Howard – International Financial Adviser – Many Paul Howards are listed on the CII register – let’s hope one of them is him!
2 out of 6 definitely with a possible 4 out of 6 – not bad Gibraltar! You definitely come out as top office of Blacktower Spain – qualified and registered?
No extra points using the libf register
************************************
edit: despite the libf register NONE of the Blacktower Spain team appear on it, this means the original score sticks.
7 out of 29 qualified and registered in the Blacktower Spain office – 75% unqualified and unregistered!
Pretty poor result Blacktower.
Would it not be better to contact the various exam bodies themselves and let them know this is going on? It probably never occurs to anyone to check that claims of exams on profiles may not be true.
What exams should we be looking for within an individual or organization? Could someone in the financial industry comment, rather than relying on a blog on here to come to a conclusion?
You are absolutely right Mr. Rprday (how do you pronounce that?). I would love for someone within the financial services industry (preferably with a pronounceable name). Strange that hundreds haven’t rushed forward…..
You would accept the word of someone from the financial services industry Mr.Rprday?
Perhaps if we labelled the qualified ones as FAs and the unqualified as Sweet FAs it might be easier. I’ll get the branding irons ready.
A lovely chuckle for a Wednesday morning! I think I might do a blog on that 🙂
You can have the exams but not be registered as this is not a prerequisite(sp?) in Spain. So it is possible that these advisers have attained the qualifications but as they are not UK based feel no need to be on the FCA register.
Not saying it is right, but there are heavy costs involved when being part of the FCA
There may be costs being FCA regulated, but here is an example of where that cost may be worth it.
https://www.blacktowerfm.com/residents-of-spain-with-uk-pensions
This article is full of mistakes. Being charitable, I would suggest that this is a result of poor knowledge rather than an attempt to mislead.
“UK-based pensions have specific tax liabilities and obligations such as a 45% lump sum death charge” No, they don’t, there is a bit more to it than that.
“Under the current rules established in 2006, all types of approved schemes have the same tax treatment as registered pension schemes”. The rules from 2006 removed the approval regime, wrong again.
Any payment from a pension that is taxed after the death of the pension member over 75 has nothing to do with Inheritance Tax. If that were the case, then the estate would be able to apply the nil-rate band to exempt part of the tax. You are mixing up tax laws here.
Struggling to find this rule- “If the dependant is 75 years of age or older, lump sums will be taxed at 45%.” Astonishing!
“A new UK/Spain DTA took effect in 2015. Under this agreement, pension funds are only taxable in the country where the recipient has tax residency. Spanish residents with UK pensions are now only subject to Spanish income tax”. Yet, in the same article;
“Even if you are not a UK resident, you will be taxed on income that originates in the UK, such as a UK-based pension. UK pension payments are taxed at the individual’s UK marginal tax rate. Currently UK income is taxed up to 45% at the top rate.” Which one is it then?
The 45% tax rate applies to income over 150,000 pounds a year. What is that, a 5 million pound fund? Lots of expats in Spain have pensions this big.
I would be interested to see how a transfer to a QROPS protects the pension from Inheritance Tax as Inheritance Tax is not applied to the payment from a pension fund in the UK or from a QROPS “In order to better protect your pension payments from income tax as well as inheritance tax, you may decide to take advantage of QROPS”
What relevance the comment “No Inheritance Tax in Malta”? This is about residents in Spain, who are probably UK domicile. You then state “Spanish residents are subject to inheritance and gift taxes at rates from 7.65% to 34%”. Do you have no compliance department that checks these blatant irregularities? An FCA regd company will ensure that all public advertising is agreed by the compliance officer first. I realise that is a cost, as Kev refers to, but it ensures compliant advertising to the public that meets set standards.
“Transferring your UK pension to Malta or Gibraltar will protect your pension from the 45% tax on lump sum payments” You conveniently forgot to mention the circumstances that would lead to that, and a half decent adviser will ensure that would not happen with a UK pension.
I would recommend that your compliance officer reviews all the QROPS undertaken by residents in Spain to ensure the transfers were made based on the correct information.
I have commented before on twitter (maybe here also, can’t remember) that qualifications are not worth the paper they are written on IF the holder is NOT authorised by the regulator to offer the services they are offering!
Unauthorised advice regardless of how qualified the person is, bars you from the FCA compensation scheme and Ombudsman services! I discovered this the hard way!
Trustees and dodgy QROPS in particular, in Mickey Mouse jurisdictions, claim to do Due Diligence on “advisers” (euphemism for scammers) they hand the management of your pension over to, and when you ask what DD was carried out, they only produce the “adviser’s” qualifications and you discover the “adviser” wasn’t regulated or licensed to give that advice. Generally they turn out to be nothing more than insurance salesmen – pond life! They generally have the bare minimum qualification – ie they can spell “investment advice” but this is usually below the minimum a regulator would accept to authorise the provision of investment advice to retail clients.
Quals are a smokescreen! Regulatory status is a better measure. At least you then have a modicum of reparation when things go wrong.
Hello there.
Could you kindly alter your information on this page regarding myself. I am an associate member of the CISI. You can test it here https://www.cisi.org/cisiweb2/cisi-website/join-us/cisi-member-directory
Thank you.
Patrick Macdonald
Blacktower Financial Management (International) Ltd
Blacktower’s advisor, David Rogers, got me into QROPS. Almost immediately one of the “investments” collapsed, but I was assured it would be only temporary. A few years later, he left to work on his own. Blacktower failed to inform of this, so when David Rogers turned up on my doorstep to find me in shock from the recent death of my wife, I believed everything he said. Without understanding anything, I agreed to move what was left of my pension into some Australian fund. Three weeks later, the fund collapsed and has remained so ever since. Thank you Blacktower and the kind of people you employ.
Was that the LM fund?